| Platinum | Mary Brown's Famous Chicken & Taters |
| Gold | PJ's Wings an Things |
| Silver | Swiss Chalet |
| Bronze | Snooty Fox |
| Top Pick | Dixie Lee |
| Top Pick | Greco Pizza Donair |
| Top Pick | Griffin's Pub & Eatery |
| Top Pick | Mingler's Restaurant & Pub |
| Top Pick | Sam Snead's Oak Grill & Tavern |
| Top Pick | ST Hubert's |