| Platinum | East Side Mario's Fredericton |
| Gold | MOCO Downtown |
| Silver | Claudine's Eatery |
| Bronze | Snooty Fox |
| Top Pick | Luna Pizza 1990 |
| Top Pick | Papa Georgio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Delight |
| Top Pick | Sam Snead's Oak Grill & Tavern |
| Top Pick | St James Gate |
| Top Pick | Vanellis |